Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Meet Our Team

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1836 Liberty Seated Silver Dollars PCGS PR-62 J-60, Gobrecht Original

$33,500.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

New Purchases

View All

1957 Dimes Roosevelt ICG MS-67

$42.00

1952 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC PF-66

$60.00

NGC MS64BN 1861-1865 A. Ludewig Tobacco Pittsburgh, PA Pvt Tokens - Civil War Tokens Pennsylvania NGC MS-64 Coppers 20% premium

$450.00

German States Bavaria Silver 2 Kreuzer 1530 Medieval Coin

$100.00

ANACS VF30 Sicily, Syracuse Hieron II AE18 Neptune Ancient Greek Coin ANACS VF-30

$80.00

"Shekel of Tyre" AR Tetradrachm 97/96 BC Ancient Greek Coin "Year 30" Phoenicia, Tyre

$1,100.00

NGC MS Constans AE Nummus 337-350 AD Ancient Roman Coin Soldiers reverse

$130.00

1926 Gold $2.5 Sesquicentennial PCGS MS-63 Sesquicentennial

$675.00

1903 Double Eagles Liberty Head PCGS MS-65+

$5,750.00

Andronicus II & Michael IX AV Hyperpyron 1295-1320 AD Byzantine Coin Great Details

$400.00

1883-O Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS-64

$90.00

1949-D Half Dollars Franklin PCGS MS-64 FBL

$80.00

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS-64

$140.00

1969-D Half Dollars Kennedy Clad NGC MS-66 TONED

$240.00

1879-S Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS MS-62 TONED

$450.00

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $33.84

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $373.41

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

Ch. 4764 1882 Brown Back $10 The Citizens National Bank of South Bend, Indiana

$1,200.00

VF Ch. 5167 1929 Ty. I $5 The First National Bank of Mishawaka, Indiana

$250.00

Series 2017A $2 San Francisco Star Note Federal Reserve Note Star Pack

$600.00

PCGS Choice UNC 63 PPQ 1935F $1 Silver Certificate , X-I block

$42.00

Series 1928 $10 Minneapolis district Star Note Federal Reserve Note

$150.00

AU Ch. 1812 1902 PB $20 The First National Bank of Cassopolis, Michigan, nice sigs

$475.00

Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $20 American National Bank of Indianapolis, Indiana

$120.00

Ch. 8764 1902 PB $10 The McDowell National Bank of Sharon, Pennsylvania

$250.00

PMG Choice About UNC Fr. 363 1891 $5 Treasury Note, Tillman-Morgan signatures

$3,200.00

PCGS Choice About New 58 Fr. 357 1891 $2 Treasury Note, Tillman-Morgan sigs

$3,000.00

PMG Gem Uncirculated 65 EPQ Series 1966 $100 United States Note

$950.00

PCGS Choice About New 58 Fr. 246 1891 $2 Silver Certificate, Windom portrait

$5,000.00

PCGS Choice About New 58 Fr. 242 1886 $2 Hancock Silver Certificate, NICE!

$2,800.00

PCGS Choice New 63 PPQ Series 1934A Mule $500 New York Federal Reserve Note

$5,500.00

UNC! Ch. 3285 1929 Ty. I $20 Old-First National Bank and TC of Fort Wayne, Indiana

$325.00

National Notes

View All

Ch. 4764 1882 Brown Back $10 The Citizens National Bank of South Bend, Indiana

$1,200.00

VF Ch. 5167 1929 Ty. I $5 The First National Bank of Mishawaka, Indiana

$250.00

AU Ch. 1812 1902 PB $20 The First National Bank of Cassopolis, Michigan, nice sigs

$475.00

Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $20 American National Bank of Indianapolis, Indiana

$120.00

Ch. 8764 1902 PB $10 The McDowell National Bank of Sharon, Pennsylvania

$250.00

UNC! Ch. 3285 1929 Ty. I $20 Old-First National Bank and TC of Fort Wayne, Indiana

$325.00

Ch. 2119 1929 Ty. I $10 First National Bank of Marshall County at Plymouth, IN

$175.00

Ch. 377 1929 $10 Ty. I First National Bank and Trust Company of La Porte, Indiana

$220.00