Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Gold Au $4,197.30 $1.68

Silver Ag $60.91 $0.03

Platinum Pt $1,695.40 $0

Palladium Pd $1,158 -$1.02

Call 317-545-7650

REGISTER LOGIN

Meet Our Team

Portrait of Spencer Sallee

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Portrait of Cory Matt Dinger

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Portrait of Cory Williams

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1887-O Morgan Silver Dollar PCGS F-12

$2,450

1888-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-63 MINT ERROR ROTATED DIES

$500

1999 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse PCGS MS-63 BN Triple Struck Obv. Die Cap

$2,000

No Date Washington DC and US Territories Clad Quarter 2009 NGC MS-64 Double Struck Obv. Die Cap

$4,500

New Purchases

View All

1798 Silver Dollars Draped Bust PCGS Genuine - XF Details Small Eagle, 13 Stars

$8,500

1881 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-64 NGC MS64 1881 James Garfield Presidential Campaign Medal "Civic Wreath"

$275

1860 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-64 RB NGC MS64RB 1860 Washington portrait E. Hill dealer in Coins etc New York

$350

1694 AUSTRIAN STATES Silver 1/2 THALER NGC AU-58 NGC AU58 Holy Roman Empire 1694 Austria Silver 1/2 Thaler City of Salzburg

$500

1852 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC AU-55 NGC AU55 (1852) Major General Winfield Scott Campaign Brass Medal

$175

1876 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-66 RB NGC MS66RB 1876 George Washington portrait Boys & Girls of America Medal

$275

Undated circa 1862 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-64 NGC MS64 circa 1862 George Washington & Andrew Jackson Silver Medal by A. Paquet

$270

1773 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-66 BN NGC MS66BN (1773) Great Britain King George II British Historical Medal

$400

1801 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-64 NGC MS64 1801 Ireland & Great Britain Union Medal Prosperity of the Kingdoms

$375

1876 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-64 RB NGC MS64RB 1876 100th Year of Independence, George & Martha Washington token

$450

circa 1860's Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-65 NGC MS65 Washington horseback, R. Lovett Jr., Die Sinker Philadelphia Token

$300

(1876) Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-66 RB NGC MS66RB A. Paquet Washington Medal, Centennial of Independence

$450

1859 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-66 NGC MS66BN 1859 Washington Cabinet Commencement Token Beautiful!

$220

1573 World Coin NGC XF-40 NGC XF40 Netherland Silver Dordrecth Duke of ALba Withdrawal

$1,200

Later Restrike of 1832 Misc. Tokens & Medals NGC MS-63 Centennial of George Washington's Birthday 32mm Token

$140

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

PCGS Ch AU 58 Comment 1934 $500 New York Federal Reserve Note Good Color

$3,200

PCGS Ch UNC 64 No Comments 1934A $500 New York Federal Reserve Note Great Color

$4,750

PMG Very Fine 20 Fr. 2 1861 $5 Philadelphia Demand Note, First US Legal Tender

$5,000

PCGS Choice XF 45 Comments 1934A $500 Mule New York Federal Reserve Note

$2,250

PCGS Very Fine 35 Comment 1934A $500 Mule Chicago Federal Reserve Note

$2,100

PCGS Very Fine 35 Comment 1934A $500 Mule Chicago Federal Reserve Note

$2,100

PCGS Very Fine 35 Comments 1934A $500 Mule Chicago Federal Reserve Note

$1,950

WWII Emergency Issue "North Africa" Series 1934A $5 Silver Certificate

$150

WWII Emergency Issue "North Africa" Series 1934A $10 Silver Certificate

$145

WWII Emergency Issue "North Africa" Series 1934A $10 Silver Certificate

$160

WWII Emergency Issue "North Africa" Series 1934A $10 Yellow Seal Silver Certificate

$130

UNC T-69 1864 $5 Confederate States of America

$110

November 29, 1775 $2 Continental Currency Printed by Hall and Sellers

$325

1868 "$3" E.H. Stein 'City of Paris' One Dollar Store Chicago, IL Ad Note

$100

1933 $1 Evening Astorian Budget - Budget Beaver Pelts, Astoria, Oregon Depression Scrip

$200

National Notes

View All

Ch. 4800 1929 Ty. I $50 The Farmers National Bank of Shelbyville Indiana

$300

PCGS Very Fine 25 1875 $5 The First National Bank of Vincennes Indiana Ch. 1873

$1,800

Ch. 2057 1929 Ty. I $20 The First National Bank of Lebanon Indiana

$145

Legacy Good 6 Comment Ch. 8447 1902 $10 PB The FNB of Coatesville, Indiana

$600

Ch. 5458 Series 1882 $20 Value Back The Marine National Bank of Milwaukee, WI

$1,000