Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Gold Au $4,659.10 -$55.85

Silver Ag $80.40 -$0.08

Platinum Pt $2,045.70 -$21.17

Palladium Pd $1,498 -$10.35

Call 317-545-7650

REGISTER LOGIN

Meet Our Team

Portrait of Spencer Sallee

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Portrait of Cory Matt Dinger

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Portrait of Cory Williams

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1883-CC Morgan Silver Dollar CACG MS 63 GSA Treasure CAC

$425

1999 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse PCGS MS-63 BN Triple Struck Obv. Die Cap

$2,000

No Date Washington DC and US Territories Clad Quarter 2009 NGC MS-64 Double Struck Obv. Die Cap

$4,500

1888-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC G-6 Misaligned Dies

$250

1978-RCM CANADA Silver CENT PCGS MS-64 BN Struck on 1977 Quarter

$4,750

1916-D Mercury Dime NGC AG-3

$900

1882 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS MS-63 BN CAC

$225

New Purchases

View All

1944 Mercury Dime ANACS AU-58 Broadstruck

$160

1935 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo ANACS AU-55 Struck Off Center

$250

1855 Liberty Seated Half Dime PCGS Genuine - AU Details (92 - Cleaned) Arrows

$200

1987 Bullion Silver Eagles PCGS MS-68 Silver Eagle

$300

1900-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC AU Details OBV MISALIGNED DIE

$300

1941-S Mercury Dime NGC AU-55 Broadstruck

$200

1945-D Half Dollars Liberty Walking NGC MS-64

$90

1944 Half Dollars Liberty Walking NGC MS-64

$90

1941 Half Dollars Liberty Walking NGC MS-64

$90

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64

$210

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 CAC

$210

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 CAC

$210

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 CAC

$210

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 CAC

$210

1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 CAC

$210

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

UNC with a stain 1935A $1 Yellow Seal "North Africa" WWII Emergency Issue

$150

Ch. 5067 1902 $5 PB The Rockville National Bank Rockville, Indiana

$300

PCGS Ch UNC 64 PPQ 1923 $1 Silver Certificate Fr. 237 Speelman-White

$335

PCGS VG8 1872 "100" Thomas Hoyt & Co. Sunnyside Chewing Tobacco NY

$125

Very Fine Series 1899 $1 "Black Eagle" Silver Certificate Fr. 236 Speelman-White

$315

Ch AU T-72 1864 50 Cents Confederate States of America Fractional

$70

Ch F Series 1914 $5 Boston district Federal Reserve Note Fr. 847a

$100

XF T-40 1862 $100 Confederate States of America, 3 interest paid stamps

$200

Ch AU Fourth Issue 50 Cents Stanton Fractional Currency Fr. 1376

$220

Ch AU First Issue 5 Cents Fractional Currency w/ monogram Fr. 1230

$100

UNC Minor Stain Fourth Issue 50 Cents Dexter Fractional Currency Fr. 1286

$200

Ch UNC Second Issue 25 Cents Fractional Currency Fr. 1283 Purple Back

$200

Ch UNC Third Issue 5 Cents Fractional Currency Spencer Clark portrait Fr. 1238

$225

Choice UNC 1935A $1 Hawaii overprinted WWII Emergency Issue Silver Certificate

$260

Choice UNC 1935A $1 Hawaii overprinted WWII Emergency Issue Silver Certificate

$250

National Notes

View All

Ch. 5067 1902 $5 PB The Rockville National Bank Rockville, Indiana

$300

Ch. 9829 1902 $5 PB The Fletcher American National Bank of Indianapolis, IN

$180

Ch. 3224 Ty. I 1929 $20 The First National Bank of Winona, Minnesota - SB

$185

Ch. 9717 Series 1902 PB $5 The Gotham National Bank of New York, NY

$325

Legacy Good 6 Comment Ch. 8447 1902 $10 PB The FNB of Coatesville, Indiana

$600

Ch. 5458 Series 1882 $20 Value Back The Marine National Bank of Milwaukee, WI

$1,000