Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Meet Our Team

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1871 Liberty Seated Silver Dollars NGC VF-35

$550.00

1937 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo NGC MS-67+ CAC

$650.00

1987-S Modern Commemorative U.S. Constitution Bicentennial PCGS PR-68 DCAM Constitution

$325.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1898-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-67+ CAC

$6,000.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

New Purchases

View All

1884-O Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-63

$70.00

1878 Morgan Silver Dollar NGC MS-64 7/8TF

$575.00

1875 Half Dollars Liberty Seated NGC PF-66

$3,150.00

1904 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-63

$625.00

1903 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-64

$600.00

1878 Gold Three Dollars $3 Indian Princess Head NGC XF-45

$1,250.00

Various Bag Lots Casino Tokens

$25.00

Mysia, Parion AR Hemidrachm 400-300 BC Ancient Greek Coin Gorgon/Bull

$150.00

Thrace, Apollonia Pontika AR Drachm 470-435 BC Ancient Greek Coin Gorgon/Anchor & Crayfish

$85.00

1936-D Classic Commemorative Columbia, South Carolina, Sesquicentennial PCGS MS-66 Columbia

$250.00

1871 Liberty Seated Silver Dollars NGC VF-35

$550.00

1937 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo NGC MS-67+ CAC

$650.00

Septimius Severus AR Denarius 196-197 AD Ancient Roman Coin RIC 96A Vows reverse

$45.00

Magnentius AE Follis Lugdunum mint 351-353 AD Ancient Roman Coin RIC 144b Victories reverse

$50.00

Celtic Lemovices AR Drachm 2nd-1st Century BC Ancient Greek Coin Horse reverse

$100.00

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Any Year - 1/10oz American Gold Eagle

As low as $343.24

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $32.86

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

PMG Fine 12 - 1854 25 Cents John Studabaker's Store, Bluffton, Indiana

$70.00

PMG Very Fine 20 - 1854 25 Cents John Studabaker's Store, Bluffton, Indiana

$85.00

PMG Fine 15 - 1854 10 Cents John Studabaker's Store, Bluffton, Indiana

$75.00

PMG Good 6 Net - 1854 10 Cents John Studabaker's Store, Bluffton, Indiana

$60.00

PMG Fine 12 - 1854 5 Cents John Studabaker's Store, Bluffton, Indiana

$70.00

Ch. 2067 1929 Ty. I $5 The City National Bank of Goshen, Indiana, Uncirculated!

$200.00

PMG VG10 1857 $1 Bank of the State, Madison, Indiana Late Redeemed in 1878!

$120.00

PMG F15 1857 $5 Bank of the State, Madison, Indiana Late Redeemed in 1879!

$175.00

PCGS Very Fine 25 Fr. 247 Series 1896 $2 "Educational" Silver Certificate

$2,400.00

PMG Very Fine 25 Fr. 224 Series 1896 $1 "Educational" Silver Certificate

$750.00

PCGS Gem UNC 66 PPQ Series 1963 $2 United States Note, Granahan-Dillon sigs

$50.00

PCGS Gem UNC 65 PPQ Series 1963 $2 United States Note, Granahan-Dillon sigs

$45.00

PCGS Gem UNC 65 PPQ Series 1963 $2 United States Note, Granahan-Dillon sigs

$45.00

PCGS Gem UNC 65 PPQ Series 1963 $2 United States Note, Granahan-Dillon sigs

$45.00

PCGS Gem UNC 65 PPQ Series 1963 $2 United States Note, Granahan-Dillon sigs

$45.00

National Notes

View All

Ch. 2067 1929 Ty. I $5 The City National Bank of Goshen, Indiana, Uncirculated!

$200.00

PMG Fine 15 NET Ch. 7718 1902 $5 First National Bank of Fairbanks, Alaska WOW

$12,000.00

Ch. 8337 1902 DB $10 The Fairland National Bank, Fairland, Indiana Tough in Large

$720.00

Ch. 4576 1929 Ty. I $20 The Citizens National Bank of Decatur, Illinois

$115.00

Ch. 2320 Series 1929 Ty. I $20 The First National Bank of Boonville, New York

$250.00

Ch. 10080 1929 Ty. I $20 The Central National Bank of Richmond, Virginia

$140.00

Series 1929 Ty. I $20 The Silver Creek National Bank, Silver Creek, New York

$225.00

Series 1902 $10 DB The Fayette National Bank of Connersville, Indiana NICE

$425.00